Numoja › Difficulty

Difficulty guide

What makes a puzzle Easy, Medium, Hard or Expert.

Numoja has four difficulty levels: Easy, Medium, Hard and Expert. Nobody labels them by hand; the engine actually solves each puzzle and decides. This page explains how, shows the real numbers from our puzzle bank, and suggests an order to practise in.

At a glance

DifficultyEngine levelNew techniques neededGivensPuzzles in bank
Easy1Full House, Hidden Single (in a box)38100
Medium2Hidden Single (in a row or column), Naked Single30100
Hard3Pointing, Claiming, Naked Pair, Hidden Pair22~27 (avg 24.3)100
Expert4Naked Triple, Hidden Triple, X-Wing21~28 (avg 24.2)100

Givens and puzzle counts come from re-checking the current puzzle bank (first batch, 400 puzzles) with the engine.

How the difficulty is decided

  1. Easiest techniques first, like a person. At every point in the solve, the engine tries the ten solving techniques from easiest to hardest and takes the first move it finds. It repeats this until the grid is full.
  2. The hardest moment sets the level. Each technique has a level. Full House and Hidden Single in a box are level 1; Hidden Single in a row or column and Naked Single are level 2; Pointing, Claiming, Naked Pair and Hidden Pair are level 3; Naked Triple, Hidden Triple and X-Wing are level 4. If the highest level used anywhere in the solve is 1 the puzzle is Easy, 2 is Medium, 3 is Hard and 4 is Expert.
  3. Only puzzles that can be finished are served. Puzzles that the ten techniques can't finish, or that have more than one solution, never make it into the bank. So at every level you can solve without guessing.

So even if almost all of a puzzle falls to hidden singles, one single naked pair halfway through makes it Hard. You can't finish without getting past that moment.

Does the number of empty cells matter?

Easy and Medium have a fixed number of givens. The engine starts from a solved grid and removes numbers one at a time, checking after each removal that the puzzle still has one solution and can still be solved with that level's techniques. It stops at 38 givens for Easy and 30 for Medium, so every Easy puzzle has 43 empty cells and every Medium puzzle has 51.

For Hard and Expert, the engine keeps removing numbers as long as the solution stays unique, then grades the result by the techniques it needs. That is why Hard puzzles have 22 to 27 givens and Expert puzzles 21 to 28. Their averages, 24.3 and 24.2, are almost identical. In other words, what separates the harder levels is not how many cells are empty but which techniques you need. Some puzzles with lots of gaps fall quickly to easy moves, and some with fewer gaps need one advanced step.

Which techniques each level really uses

Number of bank puzzles that use each technique at least once when the engine solves them (100 puzzles per level).

TechniqueEasyMediumHardExpert
Full House100100100100
Hidden Single100100100100
Naked Single0188482
Pointing009396
Claiming003250
Naked Pair002749
Hidden Pair001035
Naked Triple00058
Hidden Triple00017
X-Wing00029

Most Hard puzzles use pointing, and naked triples are the most common advanced move at Expert. The X-Wing and the hidden triple appear in only some Expert puzzles. Few Medium puzzles use the naked single, because most of them get past their hardest moment with a hidden single in a row or column.

An example from each level

The first puzzle of each level in our bank. Bold numbers are the givens.

E-001-000111223344556677889995271317932851751249724567242643914972
Easy: E-001-0001, 38 givens, 43 empty cells, 43 engine steps. Techniques used: Full House, Hidden Single.
M-001-0001112233445566778899132296387996274279221765657381
Medium: M-001-0001, 30 givens, 51 empty cells, 51 engine steps. Techniques used: Full House, Hidden Single.
H-001-0001112233445566778899832351231413994625375866179
Hard: H-001-0001, 27 givens, 54 empty cells, 55 engine steps. Techniques used: Full House, Hidden Single, Naked Single, Naked Pair.
X-001-00011122334455667788998165259538684269194138149518
Expert: X-001-0001, 28 givens, 53 empty cells, 55 engine steps. Techniques used: Full House, Hidden Single, Naked Single, Pointing, X-Wing.

A practice plan

  1. Easy: solve with hidden singles and full houses only, no notes. When you can finish a few in a row without hints, move on.
  2. Medium: learn hidden singles in rows and columns, and naked singles. Start pencilling notes into the cells where you get stuck.
  3. Hard: fill in notes for the whole grid before you start. Look for pointing and claiming first, then naked and hidden pairs.
  4. Expert: when the Hard techniques run dry, look for triples, and finally check each number for an X-Wing.

Whatever the level, when you're stuck, open only the first hint step. Knowing where to look is often enough to find the move yourself. Look up the technique the hint names on this site, and next time you'll spot it on your own.

Play now